Re: comments on cipher please
- From: "Antony Clements" <antony.clements@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 31 Oct 2006 12:54:08 +1100
<snip>
You are an amateur cipher, and you're acting amateurish. Your algorithm is<end snip>
incomplete, incomprehensible, insecure as hell, and one could add many
other in-s.
oh really? i didn't already know that... in fact i made the comment myself
several dozen times that it's an amateur cipher, and probably has minimal
security IF IT HAS ANY AT ALL!
now if you bother reading some of he replies i make to other people,
especially the last reply to mr Wagner, you would see that it is an attempt
at a runtime ECB with a CFB. now kindly quite your bitching and actually be
constructive rather than pounding on people until they give up. I'm sure you
are an intelligent man, but your comments are not intelligent at all. anyone
can say something is useless without giving reasons why it is useless.
I know it is incomplete, it will never be complete unless people make
suggestions that will help mae it complete, something that you don't do.
I do take any and all constroctive criticisms and attempt to incorporate
them into the cipher. I have even had comments from mr Schneier, even though
he essentially said he doesn't have time to analyse anything to tell me how
many breaks he could find. but the fact that he even bothered to reply shows
that it has at least some potential.
I am not going to get into a flaming contest with you, if you don't like my
posts ignore them. It's as simple as that.
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Tom St Denis
- Re: comments on cipher please
- References:
- comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Kristian Gjøsteen
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Kristian Gjøsteen
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Matthew Fanto
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Matthew Fanto
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Matthew Fanto
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Matthew Fanto
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: TC
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- Re: comments on cipher please
- From: Antony Clements
- comments on cipher please
- Prev by Date: Re: comments on cipher please
- Next by Date: Re: Notice: My 2nd crypto book finished :-)
- Previous by thread: Re: comments on cipher please
- Next by thread: Re: comments on cipher please
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
|