Re: Public disclosure of discovered vulnerabilities

From: Colonel Forbin (forbin_at_dev.nul)
Date: 06/09/05


Date: Thu, 09 Jun 2005 20:26:46 GMT

In article <bt%pe.301836$cg1.156605@bgtnsc04-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>,
Stephen Fuld <s.fuld@PleaseRemove.att.net> wrote:
>
>"Douglas A. Gwyn" <DAGwyn@null.net> wrote in message
>news:nJadnUNakc32bjrfRVn-gQ@comcast.com...
>> Colonel Forbin wrote:
>>> I think this is what Doug has been aiming at, but he hasn't really
>>> addressed the larger picture of the extrinsic factors beyond the
>>> language itself which discourage production of robust code since
>>> his point was simply that the language itself is not the culprit
>>> in most cases.
>>
>> Yes, thanks; you expressed the global issue rather well.
>>
>> I am somewhat pessimistic about the chances for fixing
>> the education and management problems that have struck
>> nationwide if not worldwide. But we don't have to fix
>> the whole thing in order to address the more limited
>> area of software security; for example, something along
>> the lines of the Underwriters' Laboratory Seal of
>> Approval might help improve the situation.
>
>There is the ISO 9000 stuff which is an attempt to do pretty much that. It
>doesn't "certify" a particular product, but the process used to produce that
>product, including design reviews, etc. I personally haven't found that ISO
>9000 certified companies produce noticibly better products than those not so
>certified, but YMMV.

IMHO, ISO 9000 is just another irrelevant nonsolution much like certification
of programmers. It hasn't addressed the root problem at all, just added a
whole new parasitic industry on top of it.

A great part of the problem, in the US at least, is a wholesale
abandonment of ethics and adoption of greed as the key driver for the
American business and investment culture. As a natural response to
this, workers have become more and more self absorbed as their life
stress mounts and they see no inspiration toward altruism from their
"leaders."



Relevant Pages

  • Re: CE compliance testing in the UK
    ... Of course it's fluff. ... DO you have the little certification sticker? ... When ISO first came out I was involved in getting the processes ... The result of the processes didn't have high quality ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: SHOPFOX DEALER PLANER QUESTION
    ... ISO is not a set of standards as the advertising ... ISO certification has two benefits. ...
    (rec.woodworking)
  • ISO 13485, how to ?
    ... an ISO 13485:2003 certification. ... I already talked to a company that is responsible for the certification ... If anyone can forward me a link to a completed ISO 13485 documentation, ... The point is that I want to avoid any consulting fees. ...
    (sci.engr.electrical.compliance)
  • ISO 9000 was: Re: Public disclosure of discovered vulnerabilities
    ... The principal of ISO 9000 is what we want: ... ISO 9000 gives us a case no PHB ... Certification means a third party checks that we do ... Bids and contracts ...
    (sci.crypt)