Re: Sociological/Psychological Phenomenon

From: ake (i.am_at_not.invalid)
Date: 06/01/05


Date: Wed, 1 Jun 2005 08:45:24 +0300


"Pubkeybreaker"
> I am curious about something.
>
> What is it about math and crypto that makes an amateur
> believe that he/she can actually come up with a new theorem
> or algorithm that has somehow been miracuously missed by
> large numbers of previous (or current) mathematicians???

How well are those cases documented when mathematicians have examined an
idea and made the conclusion that it wasn't such a good idea? Not at all, I
believe.

Maybe somebody should list all ideas which are promising at first look, but
turn out to be bad ideas at closer examination?



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Math society against amateurs
    ... > math crank claiming to have proven Fermat's Last Theorem. ... Most mathematicians haven't even heard of me. ... > can't find a single amateur mathematician being noted. ... > You believe in them, so if professional mathematicians ignore a result, ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: Math society against amateurs
    ... > My latest research is on factoring integers. ... > math crank claiming to have proven Fermat's Last Theorem. ... Most mathematicians haven't even heard of me. ... I suspect that the number of amateur mathematicians is increasing ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: James Harris is going to Pop.
    ... That has never before been seen and it chops up a lot of crap that math ... Now go read up on class number and see how wrong mathematicians got it ... And notice now the insults. ... I WILL GET MY MONEY If you fucking morons think that I will let ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: James Harris is going to Pop.
    ... Instead of ever asking questions, he insults, time for this Crackpot/Troll ... "mathematicians" decided they couldn't be bothered with telling the truth. ... That has never before been seen and it chops up a lot of crap that math ... I WILL GET MY MONEY If you fucking morons think that I will let you get ...
    (sci.math)
  • JSH: James Harris is going to POP! AGAIN !
    ... Instead of ever asking questions, he insults, time for this Crackpot/Troll ... when I am FUCKING CONCEDING HIS MAIN GODDAMN ... "mathematicians" decided they couldn't be bothered with telling the truth. ... That has never before been seen and it chops up a lot of crap that math ...
    (sci.math)