Re: How strong would randomizing data be ?

From: Skybuck Flying (
Date: 05/05/05

Date: Thu, 5 May 2005 07:20:35 +0200

"Joseph Ashwood" <> wrote in message
> "Skybuck Flying" <> wrote in message
> news:d570at$128$
> > The question is if there is such a thing as true randomness ;)
> >
> > In the end everything happens because of some sort of system ;)
> This is actually a somewhat open area of debate, no one has successfully
> proven that entropy exists, but at this point the theories suggesting it
> does not do not appear accurate.
> As to the strength of your "design" it is almost certainly flawed, and you
> haven't even given details. The reason is rather simple, you need to
> cryptographically strong pRNGs and these are in short supply unless you
> a good block cipher in CTR mode. Either way you've over designed and under
> engineered, especially in security.
> As others have noted you have basically reinvented the stream cipher,
> in a rather convoluted way. You really don't need all the layers you have
> and your reasons behind creating the design can be easily dealt with
> otherways, the short problem is dealt with through padding. That you are
> using ECB is easily addressed by switching modes, etc.

The number of layers is about the same.

My scheme might even be stronger than AES.

In AES the counter (IV) is simply incremented.

In my version the "counter" is randomized.

What I don't undestand is why it would be bad for AES in CTR mode if the
same counter is re-used...

if it is just re-used for a couple of bytes why would that be bad ?


Relevant Pages

  • Re: How strong would randomizing data be ?
    ... >> a good block cipher in CTR mode. ... > In AES the counter is simply incremented. ... It encrypts something which an attacker could known given the IV... ...
  • Re: Big Prime number prolem.
    ... Fortuna using AES in CTR mode for PRNG output. ... state update is done usign 32 pools of SHA-256 hashs. ...
  • Re: Roadside snow stratigraphy at Lake Tahoe
    ... AES wrote: ... avalanche hazard estimation. ... started using the Rose Snow Sampler. ... Driving home from winter hibernation today, noticed one face with particularly sharp clean layers about halfway up the Old Donner Pass Road, under a rock overhang which protected it from direct sun. Thicker layers up there than in similar examples alongside 28 or 89 down by the Lake! ...
  • Re: What is the speed of the fastest (secure) stream cipher?
    ... Currently there are no stream ciphers faster than AES in CTR mode in ... However interest in stream ciphers seems to have increased recently so ... If AES in CTR is definitely too slow (around 16 cycles per byte), ...
  • Re: RC4 on AMD64
    ... If the key is the same and the IV is the same and the algorithm does ... combiner at the end (all true in the case of AES in CTR mode and RC4) ...