SF: Some basic facts

jstevh_at_msn.com
Date: 04/20/05


Date: 19 Apr 2005 16:12:34 -0700

First off, I have the surrogate factoring theorem, also known as the
SFT, which is a theorem.

So, as a theorem, it can't be refuted.

That's a fact, which makes it nice for me because it's an irrefutable
point from which to handle posters.

That's a nice thing about mathematics: absolutes.

Now posters have gone on and on about why they say it can't be made
practical, but, so what?

It's still a theorem, still an absolute, still absolutely true.

I can rest on the SFT itself, without concern about practicality,
though I've looked and it has NOT been proven that it doesn't lead to
some practical factoring method from what I've seen posted.

Any such proof would be of interest, but the SFT would still be a
theorem, regardless.

Yes, I can rely on "pure math" here, as the concept is just amazingly
clever, even if it turns out it doesn't work.

James Harris



Relevant Pages

  • Re: SF: Some basic facts
    ... I agree that SFT is correct. ... > That's a nice thing about mathematics: absolutes. ... > I can rest on the SFT itself, without concern about practicality, ... can obviously be chosen to be *any* nonzero rationals ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: JSH: Objectivity, linking hyperbolas
    ... > Now I like focusing on the surrogate factoring theorem because it is ... > What makes the SFT such beautiful mathematics is that no one has put ... > forward how it maps so that you can explain it so simply. ... > So, if you graph using the SFT, the way the second hyperbola builds ...
    (sci.math)
  • Silly Factoring Theorems
    ... suppose p is k digits long. ... Then one example of a sft is the ... Thus it meets and exceeds all the requirements of ... This is where "practicality matters". ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: A theorem cant be wrong
    ... > It seems odd that I need to remind that a theorem cannot be wrong. ... > So the surrogate factoring theorem (SFT) cannot be wrong. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: JSH: A theorem cant be wrong
    ... > It seems odd that I need to remind that a theorem cannot be wrong. ... > So the surrogate factoring theorem (SFT) cannot be wrong. ...
    (sci.math)