Re: SP2 Security Center

From: Colin Nash [MVP] (x_at_x)
Date: 02/01/05


Date: Tue, 1 Feb 2005 00:14:51 -0500


"Schooltech" <schooltech@education.nz> wrote in message
news:41fee7c7$1@clear.net.nz...
> If your PC is not connected to a domain, you see in the SP2 Security
> Center:
> * A list of alert settings for the popup warnings
> * Pop up warnings appear in the taskbar system notification area such as
> "Your antivirus may be out of date."
>
> As soon as you connect your PC to a domain, all these warnings disappear.
>
> Microsoft in its infinite wisdom has not heard of domain users who aren't
> plugged into the domain all the time, such as laptop users, or network
> outages, or any other circumstance in which users of machines which are
> plugged into the network might have their machines fail to continue to be
> updated with automatic updates, or fail to receive antivirus updates.
>
> It has apparently not occurred to Microsoft that
> * since users can disconnect their machines from the network and still log
> in, if the machine is not connected to the domain for an extended period
> it
> might not receive automatic updates and thus be vulnerable
> * if the antivirus updating is not working for some reason, the machine's
> antivirus product could still become out of date with no warning to the
> user.
>
> It's a little much to expect any support from MS either for what is a new
> product. There appears not to be one single security document or any
> useful
> information on the Security Center.
>
>

That's because they assume that most domains are run by professionals who
will take their own precautions to ensure that the systems are up-to-date
(and possibly, these professionals will want to do their own testing before
deploying patches through something like SUS or SMS.) The automatic updates
+ security center features in SP2 is really geared toward pure home users,
but as others have mentioned, system admins can turn its components on or
off on domains.

-- 
Colin Nash
Microsoft MVP
Windows Shell/User 


Relevant Pages

  • Re: SP2 and Sec Center nags
    ... Disable both Security Center and Automatic Updates via Services.Msc. ... > I'm in charge of maintaining the machines in a SOHO with a handful of XP ... I recently put SP2 on all three, but because I have autoupdate ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • SP2 Security Center
    ... If your PC is not connected to a domain, you see in the SP2 Security Center: ... Pop up warnings appear in the taskbar system notification area such as ... plugged into the network might have their machines fail to continue to be ... or fail to receive antivirus updates. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.security_admin)
  • Alerts by email
    ... I have a number of Windows XP machines that I manage. ... security and application warnings and errors. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.security_admin)
  • Re: the exploit that wasnt
    ... The other Mac Book Pro? ... brought Microsoft into a security discussion about Mac OS X. ... The number of security patches, ... if you were to scan random machines on the internet for a week, how many Unix machines do you believe you would hit? ...
    (comp.sys.mac.advocacy)
  • Re: Cryptogram Comment
    ... Or had to go through setting up basic security for their ... > bother me with Windows questions. ... > machines are broken. ... and Linux and other open OS's make all patches FREE to redistribute. ...
    (sci.crypt)