Re: Who is using MSMQ?

"Roger Wolter[MSFT]" <rwolter@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:OuTljACMGHA.3104@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Sorry I wasn't specific enough. I thought if I pointed out the dots you
would be able to connect them together.

You did not provide enough information to fill in the dots, and I identified
the parts that were missing. If you wanted to, you could have simply said
that what I described was normal. Please read my reply again. You are saying
that I should have been able to determine that the behavior is normal, but
your reply was not sufficiently clear.

MSMQ and DTC are both part of Windows and installed with Windows.

Note that Andrew said that "MSMQ is not installed with SQL Server.". If MSMQ
is installed by Windows then I don't understand the relevance of whether it
is installed by SQL Server; I see no reason to say whether it is. The point
I am making is that the details were not clear to me.

When you decided to shut down DTC for whatever reason

Your implication is that it is reasonable for DTC to be running. That is
what I wanted to know. I was shutting it down because I was slighlty
concerned that it was not normal for it to be running. I have never had any
complaints from other applications that DTC was not running, so it seems
that I don't need it if SQL Server is not running.

Again, I am asking you if there is a reason to keep it up.

the dependency logic listed MSMQ as one of the things that use DTC so it
wanted you that shutting it down would affect MSMQ and SQL Server.

Yes, I know that.

Since DTC is not part of SQL Server, there's no particular reason to shut
it down when you shut down SQL Server.

Thank you. That is the answer I was asking for, or at last close enough.
Note that you did not say that from the beginning; what you did say was not
so clear.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Who is using MSMQ?
    ... Note that Andrew said that "MSMQ is not installed with SQL Server.". ... seems that I don't need it if SQL Server is not running. ... I am asking you if there is a reason to keep it up. ... wanted you that shutting it down would affect MSMQ and SQL Server. ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.security)
  • Re: Who is using MSMQ?
    ... other MVPs in other newsgroups that you need to do something about. ... Note that Andrew said that "MSMQ is not installed with SQL Server.". ... seems that I don't need it if SQL Server is not running. ... I am asking you if there is a reason to keep it up. ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.security)
  • Re: Who is using MSMQ?
    ... SQL Server is one of several services ... that sometime uses DTC to manage distributed transactions. ... to shut down DTC for whatever reason, the dependency logic listed MSMQ as ... Do you know why the SQL Server Service Manager is asking ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.security)
  • Re: Update string too long?
    ... > And we won't question to reason for this routine as you asked... ... Pro SQL Server 2000 Database Design - ... > support the full length of the inserted data? ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.programming)
  • Re: Who is using MSMQ?
    ... MSMQ is not installed with SQL ... But as Roger pointed out this is not dependant on SQL Server ... the MSDTC service it can affect other services that depend on MSDTC, ... When I use SQL Server Service Manager to shutdown SQL Server, ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.security)