Re: File sharing and wireless roaming

From: N. Miller (anonymous_at_discussions.microsoft.com)
Date: 10/09/04


Date: Fri, 8 Oct 2004 23:40:59 -0700

In article <uNE#MpYrEHA.1160@tk2msftngp13.phx.gbl>, Gary R. says...

> I tried this question on the wireless group and got no response, so here
> goes...

> Windows XP SP2 home laptop, connected at home with a wired/wireless router,
> I have a couple of folders shared over the network that I use to transfer
> misc. files and photos (MSHome is not the workgroup name I use). The
> sharing is set to full, with no password currently, as there is no need for
> the PW on the home network; the wireless is WEP protected.

Make it a need for a password on the home network; then your laptop shares
will be password protected at the cafe. More layers are better. WEP can be
cracked in some period of time. If you are encrypting tactical secrets, the
outcome of which will be accomplished within two weeks, WEP is fine.
Otherwise...

> So, when I go to a coffee place that has free wireless and I connect for
> internet purposes, will those shared folders be visible to others using that
> same wireless connection? They won't be in the same workgroup, but I'm not
> so sure that means they can't see the files or shared folders.

I was able to connect to shares on computers exposing them to the Internet,
even when not using the same workgroup name, or being in the same network
segment. "Workgroup" identities an ad hoc group of computers being used in
common projects; it was never intended as a security measure. Your best
security is password protection on the shares.

> I'm guessing that the Windows firewall would block them from writing files,
> even without a password set, since they're not in my workgroup. But I don't
> see what would stop them from viewing or copying.

The Windows Firewall probably will only protect you from people not on your
network segment. You will have established some level of trust for the
network; that will extend to any computer sharing that network segment.

> There is nothing especially private in either of them at any time, but I'd
> prefer that someone sitting in the coffee shop can't just click on "network
> places" and see my workgroup and folders there, or worse, access them. I
> can set a password for the full sharing of the folders; but regardless of
> that would like to know if they would be able to see my shared resources,
> and if so what can be done short of turning sharing off when I travel.

Even password protected shares can be see; I have done it over the Internet.
There is nothing you can do, short of binding shares to some esoteric
network protocol not normally used by cafe customers.

-- 
Norman
~Win dain a lotica, En vai tu ri, Si lo ta
~Fin dein a loluca, En dragu a sei lain
~Vi fa-ru les shutai am, En riga-lint


Relevant Pages

  • USB Hard Drive Share Failure
    ... Same drive file shares fine on any other PC but not this one. ... true cos I can access other shared folders on the PC- followed by ... The only difference between this PC and the rest of the network is ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: Windows XP Network setup problem
    ... I can now see the shared folders but I can't access them. ... I am trying to set up a home network and I am running ... >> see the workgroup name, but can't see the other computer. ... >> you might not have permission to use this network resource. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.network_web)
  • Re: Win XP Home networking problems
    ... Network Places on the laptop, and access its folders and view them; ... When I click on View workgroup computers, I still cannot see anything when I ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.network_web)
  • Re: New UserIDs created by MS .NET FRamework.
    ... Before installing this software I had the usual set of 'user folders' defined in my Win XP system, ... Network Service.NT AUTHORITY ... If you aren't using this OEM user account, you can delete it from the User Accounts applet in Control Panel. ... My Network Places - This is a graphical representation of other computers on the network and any shared network resources. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: Seeing non AD computers
    ... >>Can you see any shares at all on the machine? ... Just retested - message is "Workgroup is not accessable. ... Just retested - when I try add new network place - add as ... share - neither can see the work machine when browsing the network. ...
    (microsoft.public.win2000.active_directory)