Re: OT can't read posting.

From: Mike Easter (MikeE_at_ster.invalid)
Date: 11/25/04

  • Next message: Mike Easter: "Re: OT can't read posting."
    Date: Thu, 25 Nov 2004 21:15:09 GMT
    
    

    "Crash" Dummy wrote:
    > For some reason, the postings from "andy smart" are not being
    > rendered in my news reader (OE 6). The body is blank and there are
    > two attachments, "ATT00055.txt" and "signature.asc." The .txt file
    > contains the message and the .asc file contains a PGP signature. I
    > don't have any form of PGP installed, but I have never had any
    > problem reading PGP encoded postings before. Do you have any idea
    > what is going on?

    The structure of his postings is incompatible with your newsreader.
    Your newsreader isn't a particularly 'compliant' one and has its own
    proprietary way of doing things.

    In some newsgroups, some posters 'bend over backward' to try to help out
    those who use such newsreaders as yours, in other newsgroups there is an
    antagonism between the users of 'opposing' applications and operating
    systems.

    Andy's newsreader is T-bird and the structure of his message is
    multipart signed.with 3 mime boundary delimitors counting the epilog and
    prolog

    Prior to the prolog is the information about his message being openpgp
    signed and compliant, so you don't see that part because your newsreader
    is waiting for the mime prolog.

    After the prolog boundary, your newsreader is treating that item as the
    attachment text file. That part is containing the attribution and cite
    and his response.

    The next mime boundary is the attachment for the pgp signature, and
    interior to that it has its own begin and end, which would be respected
    and interpreted by compliant newsreaders. I'm personally against
    'unnecessary' baggagetype pgp signing, but that is a whole different
    story.

    After that pgp signature, comes the mime epilog, ie the end.

    You have a few options. You can express yourself as you have. You
    could argue that unnecessary pgp signing clutters up the newsgroup
    unnecessarily and provide some citations to support that point of view.
    You could get a different newsreader. You could killfile andy so that
    his posts won't 'annoy' you. You could do more than one of those or
    nothing.

    -- 
    Mike Easter
    

  • Next message: Mike Easter: "Re: OT can't read posting."

    Relevant Pages

    • Re: Delphi Blogsphere
      ... > I've seen newsgroup posts signed using PGP. ... until somebody writes a newsreader with digital signing ...
      (borland.public.delphi.non-technical)
    • Re: SHA-1 distributed collision search
      ... aimed at finding a SHA-1 collision, ... am curious about your pgp key, ... the signature verifies, ... newsreader view, ...
      (sci.crypt)
    • Re: to sig or not to sig?
      ... >> I don't know the details of PGP. ... > You confuse keys and signatures. ... You could send worms and viruses with a PGP signature! ... I got worm in the mail. ...
      (comp.os.linux.misc)
    • Re: PGP protection
      ... A PGP signature is a method of proving that a given message came from ... using the secret key can be verified using the public key. ... PGP and has a copy of the author's public key can verify that the ...
      (comp.os.linux.misc)
    • Help with pgp 7.03 and newsgroups
      ... Or filter Headers for PGP the Keys I know? ... And my Dialup keeps hanging up as I add the PGP Signature or Decrypt ... Simple Rules Based Tabbed Firewall with Packet Filtering, ... I can use OE6 and IE 6 and restrict them so they are safe and then ...
      (comp.security.pgp.test)