Re: How do you safely debug a firewall issue?



RS wrote:
I'm having firewall issues, from around the time of the XP update
about three weeks ago.
Now I noticed that it's not allowing me to use the Winamp Media
Library. ZoneAlarm
didn't even ask, it seems it just blocked it. When I go to my Security
Center in Control
Panel, I see the Firewall as being on, I take that to mean that I've
now got back the
Windows Firewall (which I thought was off).

No. The Security Center only shows whether an application has
registered itself as active firewall on the computer. The Windows
firewall is one of those which make the Security Center show an active
firewall.

Just check whether the Windows firewall is turned on of off in the
firewall control panel "firewall.cpl". That should tell you the
current configuration of the firewall.

How do you safely start from a relative zero point to track down a
problem? If I turn

So far you did not really describe the problem. If ZoneAlarm is
blocking something you should fix ZoneAlarm or deinstall it.

off the firewall in the Security Setting, am I only turning off the
Windows Firewall, or
am I turning off ZoneAlarm from that setting?

Which "Security Setting"? The Security Center (if that is what you
have meant) only shows the status, but you cannot change the setting
there. It just points to another control panel to make changes.

If the Security Center says you have no firewall active then you
should have no firewall running, although it is depends of course
whether ZoneAlarm correctly keeps the current status in the security
center or not...

Gerald
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Outpost firewall wont run
    ... the Windows Firewall in XP does a fantastic job ... Deconstructing Common Security Myths. ... Don't fall for software applications touted in publications relying on ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)
  • Help with security center and firewall
    ... I unistalled my Norton Internet Security and it seems that it took with ... Windows cannot display Windows firewall ... So I then go to the Windows Security Center in the Control Panel. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.security_admin)
  • Re: Constant Hacking Attemps - Pacific Bell DSL customer
    ... I use ZoneAlarm Pro as a for Firewall ... Some ISPs do offer minute security. ... ports from the same originating IP, ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)
  • Re: Paranoia or something more sinister?
    ... I should add that you want to verify that your current firewall is correctly ... > make sure that auditing of logon events is enabled in Local Security ... >> reinstalls, upgraded Norton Security to 05, I'm operating Service Pack 2 ... Search & Destroy and a Windows Firewall. ...
    (microsoft.public.security)
  • Re: Windows FW vs. ZoneAlarm or Kerio
    ... So i opened it and choosed Program Control to clear all those rules ZoneAlarm freezed together with my PC. ... Now a want to use Windows Defender with Windows Firewall instead. ... It's rather difficult to provide any information on "advanced configuring" of the Windows firewall, as it's such a barebones, rudimentary firewall; it has no advanced capabilities to be configured. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.security_admin)