Re: Vlan and Firewall

From: Walter Roberson (roberson_at_ibd.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca)
Date: 09/19/05


Date: Mon, 19 Sep 2005 12:54:38 +0000 (UTC)

In article <1127114124.536497.113260@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
 <Sid.lochan@gmail.com> wrote:
:I know a little about firewalls. In my new company right now we have
:150 systems including servers behind 198.168.165.0 IP range. We have a
:PIX 501/IOS 6.2-firewall which protects us.

PIX questions are usually better put to comp.dcom.sys.cisco.

:Now i have been told to
:create vlans for 5-6 departments as well as one vlan for servers with
:access limited to some vlans.We have 7 2950 series swtichs.
:I want to know that
:1. Do i have to change setting in PIX too for Vlans.?

Not directly: the PIX 501 has no understanding of VLANs. You might,
though, need to adjust it to handle multiple IP address ranges.

:Will firewall be
:able to see all diffrent VLANS under 1 ip range that is 192.168.165.0

No. And multiple VLANs with a single IP address range is -usually-
asking for trouble.

:2. IF i created vlans on switches then how i'll direct them to use
:Firewall to gain access to VPN and Internet.?

You cannot, not with a PIX 501.

A PIX 501 is not an appropriate PIX model for 150 internal devices,
not unless only a fraction of those devices need to communicate
with the outside world.

The architecture you will need to adopt will depend upon whether
those VLANs need to be firewalled from each other, or whether the
VLANs exist for broadcast reduction purposes instead of for access
control purposes.

If the VLANs exist for access control purposes, you will need
a firewall that handles VLANs directly, or one with
multiple physical interfaces (with you breaking out one VLAN
per physical interface.)

If the VLANs exist for traffic control purposes, then if you
want to stick with the PIX 501, you need an internal router
or layer 3 switch such as a Cisco 3550 or Cisco 3750.

Cisco firewalls that will handle 6 VLANs include:

- Cisco PIX 515/515E with an Unrestricted license, running
  PIX 6.2 or 6.3
- Cisco PIX 520 running PIX 6.2 or PIX 6.3
- Cisco PIX 525 with Restricted or Unrestricted license, running
  PIX 6.2 or 6.3
- Cisco PIX 535 with Restricted or Unrestricted license, running
  PIX 6.2 or 6.3
- [if I recall correctly] Cisco PIX 515/515E, 525, or 535, running
  PIX 7.0
- the new Cisco ASA Security Appliance series, running 7.0 software

Notes:
- The 520 will not be supported beyond 6.3
- the 515E is about 1/3 faster than the 515
- most 515 would require a memory upgrade to run PIX 7.0. Newer
  515E do not require a memory upgrade; older 515E do.

-- 
   Look out, there are llamas!


Relevant Pages

  • Re: [fw-wiz] Cisco 2811 vs. ASA 55xx
    ... Cisco ASA units are the replacements/upgrades for the PIX. ... "Is the lack of flexibility of the ASA justified by the higher performance? ... I'm not real sure what you're trying to do security-wise with a Cisco router that a Cisco firewall appliance cannot do. ...
    (Firewall-Wizards)
  • Cisco PIX 515E vs. Fortinet Fortigate-300
    ... Firewall Evaluation ... Cisco PIX 515E vs. Fortinet Fortigate-300 ... Fortigate firewall. ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)
  • Re: [fw-wiz] Pix - portmap translation creation failed
    ... Cisco Secure PIX ... Firewall Advanced 2nd ed." and found this ... of the FWSM and he claimed that it was only for management ...
    (Firewall-Wizards)
  • RE: Auditing Router and Firewall - Checklist and Utils
    ... seems like I missed it and will try out PLA/FWANALOG for PIX log gathering. ... Treat input configuration as a PIX/ASA/FWSM-based Cisco firewall. ... Auditing Router and Firewall - Checklist and Utils ...
    (Security-Basics)
  • Re: Cisco PIX or GN-1000
    ... > I currently have a GB-1000 from GTA as my firewall, ... > support costs etc I am looking to change from GB-1000 and get a Cisco ... I can't speak for the GB-1000, but I recently got my hands on a PIX 501. ... Haven't tried setting up IPSec yet, but I know Cisco ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)