Re: Problems with Norton Firewall 2002

From: Joseph V. Morris (jvmorris@erols.com)
Date: 04/26/02


From: "Joseph V. Morris" <jvmorris@erols.com>
Date: Fri, 26 Apr 2002 16:53:57 -0400

Sabine,

Hmmm, rather odd that . . . .

"Sabine" <sabine_no_spam@blueyonder.co.uk>
. . . .

| Date: 26/04/2002 Time: 18:08:59
| Connection: mtgodownloads.wizards.com(63.249.27.51): http(80) from
| sabine(62.30.121.29): 3101, 0 bytes sent, 266 bytes received,
1:33.955
| elapsed time

Okay, that's obviously off the Connections tab. And from the Firewall tab
all you have is:

| Date: 26/04/2002 Time: 18:07:25
| An instance of "C:\Program Files\wizards of the coast\magic
| online\magic.exe" is preparing to access the Internet for the first time

That's it in the firewall tab? Nothing else at all around 18:06:59 to
18:10:59? For example, no "Unused Port Blocking" or "Implicit Block rule"
entries? That sounds very strange.

Let me think . . . . The only way that I can see that a communication
might get blocked but not show in the firewall events logs would be for it
to be for an IP address indicated as being in a Restricted Range in the
Internet Zone Control of the NIS Console. Do you have any entries in the
Restricted tab of the Internet Zone Control pane of the NIS Console?
(Especially for IP addresses around 63.249.xx.yy?)

Also, can you find _any_ rules for magic.exe in the Access Control Pane of
the NIS Console? If so, have you taken a look at them to see if they are
set to BLOCK communications but have logging DISABLED? That's about all I
can think of, at the moment.
|
| Nothing else around this time under any of the tabs, but the programm
was
| just sitting there, not downloading any files or doing anything ?
|
| If I switch the firewall off, it works fine.

Which definitely makes it sound firewall-related.

| This is starting to bug me, as I would like to play, but I am not sure
how
| bad it is to turn the firewall off.

I can't knowledgably advise you on that. I don't know this game and
particular and I don't run Internet-enabled games in general. All I can
say is that I would be quite reluctant to run a multi-player
internet-enabled game with no firewall in place to protect me.

There is a possibility that the game relies on some TCP/IP protocol that
NIS will not permit by default. (Indeed, there are some mainstream
applications like NetMeeting that have the same problem; NetMeeting
uses -- or did at any rate, the H.323 protocol, which NIS does (or did)
not PERMIT.)

I also checked at
http://www.practicallynetworked.com/sharing/app_port_list.htm#Games , but
I don't see your game listed there.
. . . .

--
Regards,
    Joseph V. Morris
    jvmorris@erols.com
    ICQ #29438199

This is a NEWSGROUP message; except for privacy reasons, please respond therein; an e-mail COPY is always appreciated, of course. Almost all electrons used in the creation of this message were recycled. No electrons used in the production of this message were harmed or mistreated in any manner.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Problems with Norton Firewall 2002
    ... internet permits. ... You wont find the game listed on the list, as it is in Beta testing. ... So it looks like, the only way to play it, is by switching off the firewall. ... that's obviously off the Connections tab. ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)
  • Please help me get started
    ... in the exceptions tab that were blocked by the firewall ... I originally miunderstood the exceptions tab and added ... I restarted IIS by clicking disconnect and the clicking ... If you have Windows SP2 installed it will cause you ...
    (microsoft.public.vsnet.general)
  • Re: xp professional security mystery
    ... Products to download/use: ... I turned off the automatic startup of the 3rd party firewall ... turned back on the windows firewall for the wireless ... general tab ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)
  • Re: Cannot share Printer on Network
    ... Computer Name tab you will see the name of the workgroup. ... Windows Firewall, on the exceptions tab be sure that the files and printer ... running Win XP Home Edition and 2 notebooks connected ... I set up Printer sharing following instructions form Microsoft's site ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)
  • Re: Only 1 PC at a time will show in workgroup
    ... The Windows firewall is off on boths PCs ... TCP/UDP port 445 open on router. ... I'm used to the old tab where you can assign users and rights. ... Windows Firewall, you can Enable NetBT. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.network_web)