Re: 256-bit Camellia vs 256-bit AES - Which is better?

I was mentioning Fiestel Network in general. The comment wasn't implied directly on AES and/or DES specifically.
As such I would still maintain that the essence of Fiestel remains in its simplicity of Encryption and Decryption process which are reversal of the process itself.

"The Feistel structure has the advantage that encryption and decryption operations are very similar, even identical in some cases, requiring only a reversal of the key schedule" -Wikipedia

Precisely the similarities between AES and DES are -

AES Round Key addition corresponds to DES XOR of subkey material with the input to function f.
AES Mixcolumn corresponds to DES XOR of function f output with the left half block.
AES ByteSub corresponds to function f in DES.
AES ShiftRow corresponds to DES permutation P.


On Feb 18, 2009, at 12:01 PM, Terra Frost wrote:

On Tue, Feb 17, 2009 at 6:08 PM, Shailesh Rangari <shailesh.sf@xxxxxxxxx > wrote:

- both use the 'Fiestel Network' (first used in Lucifer & DES). Its essence
is Decryption is done by Reversing the order of Encryption.

That's incorrect. In DES, the only difference between the encryption
and decryption is the order in which the round keys are used. That's
pretty much the definition of a Fiestel Network.

In AES, in contrast, the differences between encryption and decryption
are a bit more pronounced. Take a look at fips-197.pdf#page=25 and
fips-197.pdf#page=19. The only function shared by both is
AddRoundKey. SubBytes and InvSubBytes differ in that they use
different S-Boxes, InvShiftRows and ShiftRows shift the rows in
opposite directions, and MixColumns and InvMixColumns with a different
fixed polynomial.

fips-197.pdf can be found here:

Relevant Pages

  • Re: DMSII Encryption - does it exist?
    ... encryption and is easy to implement. ... I was unaware of TEA, so thanks for pointing it out. ... Isn't there an implementation of DES that is used for the ... There are several public domain implementations of AES (the DES ...
  • AES design - can you help me to understand
    ... I have been reading this article to learn more about modern cipher design ... Is what follows a generally correct understanding. ... DES uses a key dependant transformation in every round? ... If one ran DES and AES for and equal number of rounds - say 10: ...
  • Re: AES design - can you help me to understand
    ... I may have incorrectly assumed that the first was the strategy used in AES? ... And this one may be a key dependant scrambling round similar ... Both AES and DES take your secret key and stretch it with a key ... If you really want to compare DES to another cipher compare it to CAST5 ...
  • Re: commutative property of algorithms
    ... moving output bits to input bits, do you pass through all combinations ... It is extremely unlikely that AES forms a single ... with DES. ... The big question is that by knowing as much as NSA is supposed to ...
  • MITKRB5-SA-2009-004 [CVE-2009-4212] integer underflow in AES and RC4 decryption
    ... MIT krb5 Security Advisory 2009-004 ... integer underflow in AES and RC4 decryption ...