RE: Encryption question

From: Gene LeDuc (
Date: 02/25/04

  • Next message: Lars Georg Paulsen: "Re: Encryption question"
    To: "'Preston, Tony'" <>
    Date: Wed, 25 Feb 2004 12:45:12 -0500

    Alice encrypts the message to Bob using Bob's public key and then signs it
    using her private key. Bob verifies that the message is from Alice by using
    her public key to check the signature and then decrypts the message with his
    private key. The encryption only hides the contents, it does not
    authenticate the message. The signing authenticates the message but does
    not hide the contents. You need both if you want to have a secure

    -----Original Message-----
    From: Preston, Tony []
    Sent: Tuesday, February 24, 2004 11:01 AM
    Subject: Encryption question

    Tony Preston
    Systems Engineer, AS&T Inc.
    Division of L3 Corporation
    (609) 485-0205 x 181

    I have what is a rather basic question... I probably am missing something
    so I thought I would ask here.

    Alice and Bob both have a public and private key.

    Alice encrypts her email to Bob using his public key. Sends the email and
    Bob decrypts it using his keys..

    Since both Bob and Alice's public keys are known, Why can't I take Alice's
    public key and create a key pair using any other private key. Now, I fake
    an electronic signature from Alice using the pair I created and send a bogus
    encrypted message to Bob with my "fake" Alice signature. Bob checks the
    signature by using the public key and it is valid. Bob assumes the message
    is from Alice...

    What prevents me from spoofing someone's electronic signature this way?



  • Next message: Lars Georg Paulsen: "Re: Encryption question"

    Relevant Pages

    • Re: Searchindexer -- for whose benefit?
      ... If the OTP is a 32 Gb MicroSD card, they can exchange a pair of email ... How does the recipient know he has your correct public key? ... Lets call you Alice, and the other guy Bob. ...
    • Re: GPG
      ... In a practical sense, only Bob may decrypt ... Alice on the way to Bob and prevent it from reaching Bob. ... Alice may encrypt the message with Bob's public key, ... the others) before issuing their certificates. ...
    • Re: Simple authenticated channel
      ... protocols (in this case, I assume Bob uses a DH keypair), followed by ... It is assumed Alice already has an authetic copy of Bob's public key. ... The attacker therefore does not hold k, ...
    • Practical improvement of DH-ElGamal scheme
      ... Improving DH-ElGamal public key encryption scheme can be done in ... For person Alice: ... Linking between 2 persons (Alice and Bob): ... Attacking this encryption scheme: ...
    • Re: Why everyone uses envelopes but few encrypt emails?
      ... After making sure the real Bob has signed ... Another improvement that can be made to EaSecure is to allow the user ... to independently verify the "finger print" of the public key. ... every system where the security critical message is sent before key ...