RE: Something about ISA Server 2000...

From: Los, Ralph (
Date: 10/25/01

Message-ID: <A86EB3E9F548D411AA6B00B0D020F534DB9C98@ENVESTMAIL>
From: "Los, Ralph" <>
To: "'Progenit Service S.r.l.'" <>,
Subject: RE: Something about ISA Server 2000...
Date: Thu, 25 Oct 2001 10:56:06 -0500


        Unfortunately, yes I have both experience and opinion. I started to
play around with ISA 2000 a while ago, and now I run 3 CheckPoint FW-1's.
Nothing beats a CheckPoint, in my book, BUT, Netscreen is a great little
box, and Watchguard is worth the price as well for smaller offices.

        I'd stay away from ISA as a firewall, trust me, it's not something
you want to have to deal with...<shudder>....and I'm a Microsoft fan.


Ralph M. Los
Asst. Vice-President, Internet Systems and Security
(312) 827-3945 (direct)
(312) 296-9003 (wireless w/voicemail)
* If you haven't been hacked, you don't know where your vulnerabilities lie*

-----Original Message-----
From: Progenit Service S.r.l. []
Sent: Thursday, October 25, 2001 5:10 AM
Subject: Something about ISA Server 2000...

Hi all,

has someone an opinion (good or bad....)concerning ISA Server 2000 installed
as firewall? How many differences are among this software solution from
Microsoft and Check Point Firewall-1, Netscreen 10/100, Watchguard or Cisco

Any help would be appreciated.


Giancarlo Ballestracci
Technical Support
Progenit Service S.r.l. Agenzia TENOVIS-NEWTEL Telecommunications -
Information Security - New Technologies Tel 055-456336 Fax 055-452330

Relevant Pages

  • Re: ISA Server versus Checkpoint Firewall
    ... Also, there is more to "stateful" than you describe; it goes all the way to L7, something Checkpoint doesn't yet do. ... Checkpoint is only recently starting to realize the value of application-layer filtering; something ISA has had for years. ... ISA Server can be fairly easy to just plug in, ... Unfortunately that can often be a bad thing as it is very easy to misconfigure a firewall and the ...
  • Re: How to allow WS FTP client behind Checkpoint NG with AI
    ... The reason for using ISA server in Cache-only mode is because it has a ... As there are not too many users using FTP clients, ... rule in Checkpoint to allow FTP based on user authentication (i.e user ...
  • Coexisting with another firewall?
    ... Does anyone know if you can bring up an ISA server within an existing network ... which all ready has a firewall (CheckPoint)? ...
  • How does Checkpoint VPN-1 on the Isa Server 2004 ???
    ... I opened needed ports for the programme of Checkpoint VPN-1 from Isa Server ... from remote desktop of my computer that I made vpn connection before. ... All Outbound Traffic confirmed me on Isa server for tcp and udp ..What can I do any more?? ...
  • Re: Basic External Firewall Testing?
    ... putting the checkpoint firewall on the inside. ... vulnerability websites for known vulnerabilities. ... the advantage to putting firewall-1 inside the ISA server would ...