Re: Re: Red Hat vs Debian Linux: overall security



Only question is, why leave all of the packages you don't need installed after installation. Is this a Desktop installation, or a server installation?
I have vast experience with Ubuntu (debian derived) and FC1-5.

After an install on ubuntu you can simply do a:
pkg-query -W --showformat='${Installed-Size} ${Package}\n' | sort -nr | less

And start: apt-get remove --purge <package name>
on all of the packages not needed.

Also, ubuntu seems to announce vulnerability fixes to the lists far quicker than RedHat (if redhat ever even announces a fix). Ubuntu also include them into their package repository much quicker.

With that said, and due to the topic description, I won't even stress the fact that Ubuntu/Debian Desktop is far more stable than Fedora Desktop, not only tested by me, but by dozens of other workstations near mine (nvidia driven).

You can only really judge security based on non 3rd party package inclusion, and also after your fw rule-sets are in place along with all other policies... otherwise you're the total opposite of openbsd which includes no packages by default :) and has never been hacked after a default install... oh wait, I forgot about the ssh exploits... and the others not to mention.



Relevant Pages

  • RE: redhat-list Digest, Vol 11, Issue 18
    ... Re: Missing packages ... RedHat Network doesn't work ... squid proxy installation ...
    (RedHat)
  • Re: distributions: UBUNTU vs DEBIAN
    ... Its focus is on providing 1) a "universal" operating system, that is, one suited to the widest possible variety of applications, and 2) a system composed entirely of free software, and 3) a stable and dependable computing environment. ... Packages move from the unstable area into testing after a QA process and a waiting period. ... Ubuntu is known for shipping very recent versions of GNOME as well as their focus on easy installation and use. ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Now what?
    ... lots of files but as a Windows user of many years I'm ... Ubuntu is a Debian based distro with Gnome as it's default desktop ... because the first thing I always add to a new Ubuntu installation ... the current list of available packages, ...
    (uk.comp.os.linux)
  • Re: Good Red Hat install
    ... quickly I found that it can be quite difficult to trim Redhat down to what ... option so you can pick and choose your packages on an individual basis. ... installation; I can get it under 300 megs if I'm careful and have a very ... Thinking About Security Training? ...
    (Security-Basics)
  • Advice on tulip driver
    ... as root user xsane finds the scanner but as a normal user xsane ... > First you need to run apt-get update to read the list of packages. ... I removed the existing KDE installation: ... > Probing devices to guess BIOS drives. ...
    (Debian-User)