Re: Red Hat vs Debian Linux: overall security



A quick trawl through my AUSCERT advisories from 05/05 - present day shows the following results on subject searches:

Debian: 473
DSA (debian security advisories): 180
Redhat: 147

I went to the Open Source Symposium recently (thanks for the psp!) which was sponsored by Red Hat. They provided some interesting statistics regarding security issues, make of them what you will, but I found them quite interesting. Anyways here's a few of them:

70% of all attacks are now targeted at applications, not operating systems

41.7% of reported CVE vulns are stopped by ExecShield

Time taken to fix critical flaws from the time its available to the public till the time its fixed:

0 day - 73%
1 day - 95%
2 day - 100%

I don't have a great deal of exposure to debian, however I doubt that either distro is inherently more insecure than the other.

--jason

PS. I'm in no way affiliated or associated with RedHat, merely an end user.


tjanas@xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
I am evaluating the overall security of Red Hat linux vs Debian. I've been told that Debian has many more vulnerabilities than Red Hat. I've also been told that Red Hat is quicker to release security patches than Debian is for the "stable" release. Can someone point me to a good overall assessment of the two? Using this tool: www.securityfocus.com/bid I see that Debian has 17 pages worth of issues but Red Hat has surprisingly few. Am I misinterpreting the results from this tool?





Relevant Pages

  • Re: Moving from Redhat to Debian
    ... I moved to debian from redhat a little over a year ago. ... the there are a number of package ... aged enough in unstable to vet their most glaring bugs. ...
    (comp.os.linux.misc)
  • Re: Debian for Joe Average
    ... >> If I should advice somebody new to Linux, I would say RedHat, that's ... I don't say RedHat is better than Debian, ... If he's not really Joe Average he'll find out that RPM stinks (like I ... The goal should be to get people to use Linux, ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Debian for enterprise
    ... *Looks into crystal ball* I predict that you are using Redhat 9. ... most commercial 'linux' packages seem to be developed for Redhat. ... > some specifics to argue in favor of adopting Debian, ... Security updates for Debian-stable tend to be quick. ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Debain over Redhat
    ... Here's why I switched to debian over redhat and mandrake... ... I started running Linux with RedHat Linux about 3 ... > nowadays for a RedHat system and its possible updates when they become ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Debain over Redhat
    ... > I guess what I want to find out is, is there any reason why Debian would ... > not be able to do the job that they are suggesting Redhat for, ... I started running Linux with RedHat Linux about 3 ... Debian compared to the RedHat way is the way how system updates are ...
    (Debian-User)