RE: Diebold Global Election Management System (GEMS) Backdoor Acc ount Allows Authenticated Users to Modify Votes

From: David Brodbeck (DavidB_at_mail.interclean.com)
Date: 09/27/04

  • Next message: Chip Andrews: "Re: New whitepaper "The Phishing Guide"" 
    To: 'Claudius Li' <aprentic@sectae.net>, bugtraq@securityfocus.com
Date: Mon, 27 Sep 2004 10:01:14 -0400

    > -----Original Message-----
    > From: Claudius Li [mailto:aprentic@sectae.net]

    > So my question is, given that this seems to be a solved
    > problem why is there so much debate on finding the solution?
    > Surely I am missing something obvious.

    You're missing the social dynamics around it. There are several parties
    involved:

    - State officials who actually pick the voting equipment. They generally
    are politicians, with a background in law or business. They don't
    understand the complicated technical issues behind electronic voting.

    - Companies who build the voting equipment. Their motive is profit. They
    want to get a marketable product out quickly and cheaply. They perceive
    (correctly) that the audience they're selling to does not understand or care
    about complicated security issues, and can be easily impressed by trivial
    but sophisticated-looking features.

    - The public. They don't understand these issues either, and they have a
    short attention span.

    - The news media. They don't push security issues because they lack good
    visuals and don't fit into a 15-second news spot. Anything longer and
    they'll lose their audience (see above.)

    - Computer scientists and voting activists. They *do* understand the
    issues, but are unable to explain them in a way the news media, the public,
    and state officials find compelling and understandable. The companies who
    build the equipment can easily label them as alarmists or conspiracy
    theorists.

  • Next message: Chip Andrews: "Re: New whitepaper "The Phishing Guide""

    Relevant Pages

    • RE: Diebold Global Election Management System (GEMS) Backdoor Acc ount Allows Authenticated Users
      ... > - State officials who actually pick the voting equipment. ... > that the audience they're selling to does not understand or care ... > issues, but are unable to explain them in a way the news media, the public, ... Any country where the average attention span is only 15 seconds is not fit ...
      (Bugtraq)
    • Re: Boondocks 7-29
      ... Funniest Boondocks in quite some time. ... > news media to any member of a minority group who goes missing. ... I see Fox and CNN coverage of this story and it *does* play like ...
      (rec.arts.comics.strips)
    • Re: Boondocks 7-29
      ... mainstream news media, who keep giving us the latest up-to-the-minute ... "updates" on the fact that there's no new news to update on this ... member of a minority group who goes missing. ...
      (rec.arts.comics.strips)
    • Re: Missing teen actually just being a whore
      ... The news media is really into stories about missing women. ... gal from Alabama who went missing in Aruba. ...
      (soc.men)