Re: [Full-disclosure] Re: blocking tor is not the right way forward. It may just be the right way backward.

Michael Holstein <michael.holstein@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

First, I'm a long time supporter of Tor and a staunch advocate of
anonymity and privacy.

I also believe your interpretation of the Internet is a bit...
distorted. :)

We're not talking about authenticated websites here (perhaps I should
have made that more clear), nor are we talking about using TOR, etc.
for malicious purposes.

For the purpose of this (largely theoretical) argument, I meant
"publicly accessible, non-authenticated websites".

And you're trying to justify unrestricted access to those public places
based on what amounts to a "discrimination" argument. A fallacious

Choosing to be anonymous isn't something you are, it's something you do.
A conscious choice, not an unavoidable consequence of your state of
being like race/color or sexual orientation. Consequently, it's a
quality that has no moral or legal protection.

Operators of public places certainly *do* have the right to regulate
access based on the conscious choices their prospective patrons. A
restaurant, for example, can restrict access with an arbitrary dress
code along the lines of "suit and tie". They can even enforce that
policy according to time of day if they wish.

Operating a "public access" entity doesn't mean you abdicate all your
rights to limit access, it only means you're obligated to not limit
access based on certain criteria. You still have every right to set
non-discriminatory standards, and enforce them as you see fit as long
as the practice doesn't breach the rights of your patrons.

Now what beside a clothing choice, is Tor? :)

Hand Crafted on Fri. Jun 09, 2006 at 13:27

Outside of a dog, a book is a man's best friend.
Inside of a dog, it's too dark to read.
-- Groucho Marx

Full-Disclosure - We believe in it.
Hosted and sponsored by Secunia -

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Something to read
    ... Truecrypt, ... These programs offer a good degree of both anonymity and privacy. ... Tor, then it seems like a way to hide what you are doing. ... One of the most useful attributes of Tor are its hidden services. ...
  • Re: Anonymous Surfing Providers
    ... Setting up and testing tor ... and style coming from an "anonymous" remailer user. ... If you want total anonymity so you can be an annoying prat, ... dozen other reasons why commercial services are preferable to the ...
  • Re: Privacy should be the topic here, not (from a advocate)
    ... your ISP can see everything you do as your data goes to TOR ... I plainly said proxies, not tor. ... Remailers have been around ... Before remailers there was no real anonymity in Usenet or email. ...
  • Re: Something to read
    ... These programs offer a good degree of both anonymity and privacy. ... Tor will install Privoxy. ... One of the most useful attributes of Tor are its hidden services. ...
  • Re: Bad news about Tor
    ... similar to TOR but without the limitations on bandwidth. ... Tor matures out of its development/experimental phase these services ... so any anonymity at subscription time is rendered totally useless. ... There's no difference at all between an entry node on Tor network ...